Talk:IDigBio Retreat 2015: Difference between revisions

From iDigBio
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Line 5: Line 5:


==Ideas for discussion topics at the Retreat==
==Ideas for discussion topics at the Retreat==
'''General discussion''' (after outline in a.m. from David, Larry)
* Share information from our meeting with NSF, including the new cooperative agreement and panel review summary
* Share information from our meeting with NSF, including the new cooperative agreement and panel review summary
* Everyone watch this video together (DP, KL, MC)
* Status update about the project
**[https://www.idigbio.org/sites/default/files/workshop-presentations/tdwg-2015/data-training-programmes-TDWG2015.mp4 Data training programmes in large natural history museums to tackle their digital challenges] Dimitris Koureas & Clare Valentine, NHM
** Status of the portal and use
** Scope of data storage (ACIS)
** Role of postdocs and students in iDigBio — what are they supposed to be doing?
** Citizen Science
** K-12 initiatives
 
'''Sustainability'''
* How to make our training sustainable
* How to make our training sustainable
** Converting our training materials for posterity/sustainability
** Converting our training materials for posterity/sustainability
*** Perhaps partner with Coursera (or a firm like them)
*** Perhaps partner with Coursera (or a firm like them)
** Funding for participant support will be declining after 2017
** Funding for participant support will be declining after 2017
* Tools Knowledge in the Community
** Developing a strategy for sharing what tools are out there
*** Example: [http://www.biovel.eu/ Biovel]
* Sharing information about skills researchers need to use particular tools
** Could get lots of info from iPlant and Data Carpentry about the skills problems people run into when trying to use any of the community tools for research.
*** Use this to strategically point people to where they can transform their data, or learn a skill.
** NOTE: skills needed are mostly the ''same across the data providers and researchers'' based on the experience of COLLAB-IT, Data and Software Carpentry.
* Website update and sustainability
** Increase role of community in maintaining content -> larger role for Wiki; lesser role for Drupal
** Content organization/re-organization
** Facelift? (In consultation with Jeremy -  he is against this.: JM)
* Sustainability issues for iDigBio + TCNs
* Sustainability issues for iDigBio + TCNs
** Historical Knowledge and Documents
** Historical Knowledge and Documents
Line 31: Line 27:
**** How do we include these TCNs in future summits?
**** How do we include these TCNs in future summits?
**** Is there a role for some Video Exit Interviews (oral interviews), to capture this knowledge? Perhaps Shari and Betty could set something up?
**** Is there a role for some Video Exit Interviews (oral interviews), to capture this knowledge? Perhaps Shari and Betty could set something up?
* Automation
'''Website update and sustainability'''
** Increase role of community in maintaining content -> larger role for Wiki; lesser role for Drupal
** Content organization/re-organization
** Facelift? (In consultation with Jeremy -  he is against this.: JM)
*Mendeley vs. Biblio
** Improved discoverability & functionality?
** All content in one location?
** Get a Library Science grad student to help us with our document repository concerns (I asked Greg R. to look for someone: JM)
'''Tools Knowledge in the Community'''
** Developing a strategy for sharing what tools are out there
*** Example: [http://www.biovel.eu/ Biovel]
* Sharing information about skills researchers need to use particular tools
** Could get lots of info from iPlant and Data Carpentry about the skills problems people run into when trying to use any of the community tools for research.
*** Use this to strategically point people to where they can transform their data, or learn a skill.
** NOTE: skills needed are mostly the ''same across the data providers and researchers'' based on the experience of COLLAB-IT, Data and Software Carpentry.
* Everyone watch this video together (DP, KL, MC)
**[https://www.idigbio.org/sites/default/files/workshop-presentations/tdwg-2015/data-training-programmes-TDWG2015.mp4 Data training programmes in large natural history museums to tackle their digital challenges] Dimitris Koureas & Clare Valentine, NHM
* The value of blitzes and hackathons
'''Value added services'''
* Annotations workflows - Analyzing the needs, expectations and desires of submitters, curators, and observers around the collection and presentation of annotations.
* The new iDigBio Outlier Detection and Documentation by Collectors (or the ODD Collectors) Working Group (Austin and Katie S)
'''E&O'''
* New directions for the Libraries of Life Augmented Reality app and cards; sustainability of them (Austin)
* New directions for WeDigBio and its sustainability (Austin and Libby)
'''Other'''
* Topics that come up at the Summit:
* Topics that come up at the Summit:
** [https://goo.gl/SwdHGv Day 1 Discussion Group Summaries]
** [https://goo.gl/SwdHGv Day 1 Discussion Group Summaries]
** [https://goo.gl/4J8UC1 Day 2 Discussion Group Summaries]
** [https://goo.gl/4J8UC1 Day 2 Discussion Group Summaries]
** Suggestion for Summit VI: emphasize use of the data in research and E&O; less on progress at the TCNs
** Suggestion for Summit VI: emphasize use of the data in research and E&O; less on progress at the TCNs
* Automation
* Mendeley vs. Biblio
** Improve discoverability
** Keep iDigBio content and published articles separate
* Get a Library Science grad student to help us with our document repository concerns (I asked Greg R. to look for someone: JM)
* "Common knowledge" about the project
** Status of the portal and use
** Scope of data storage (ACIS)
** Role of postdocs and students in iDigBio — what are they supposed to be doing?
** Citizen Science
** K-12 initiatives
* The value of blitzes and hackathons
* Annotations workflows - Analyzing the needs, expectations and desires of submitters, curators, and observers around the collection and presentation of annotations.
* Issue certificates to collections that participate in ADBC, perhaps meeting some quota set by iDigBio.
* Issue certificates to collections that participate in ADBC, perhaps meeting some quota set by iDigBio.
*The new iDigBio Outlier Detection and Documentation by Collectors (or the ODD Collectors) Working Group (Austin and Katie S)
*New directions for the Libraries of Life Augmented Reality app and cards; sustainability of them (Austin)
*New directions for WeDigBio and its sustainability (Austin and Libby)

Revision as of 13:20, 18 November 2015

Ideas regarding the Retreat format

  • Breakout groups
  • One large discussion group
  • Presentations

Ideas for discussion topics at the Retreat

General discussion (after outline in a.m. from David, Larry)

  • Share information from our meeting with NSF, including the new cooperative agreement and panel review summary
  • Status update about the project
    • Status of the portal and use
    • Scope of data storage (ACIS)
    • Role of postdocs and students in iDigBio — what are they supposed to be doing?
    • Citizen Science
    • K-12 initiatives

Sustainability

  • How to make our training sustainable
    • Converting our training materials for posterity/sustainability
      • Perhaps partner with Coursera (or a firm like them)
    • Funding for participant support will be declining after 2017
  • Sustainability issues for iDigBio + TCNs
    • Historical Knowledge and Documents
      • Do TCNs have robust plans for sharing developed workflows / protocols / policies (on digitization, imaging, archiving, communication strategies,...)
      • Do they archive plans for these documents?
        • Can we provide this?
      • TCN Staff (at high, middle, and in-the-trenches) are amassing a wealth of knowledge about digitization. When their funding ends, a great deal of this may be lost.
        • How do we include these TCNs in future summits?
        • Is there a role for some Video Exit Interviews (oral interviews), to capture this knowledge? Perhaps Shari and Betty could set something up?
  • Automation

Website update and sustainability

    • Increase role of community in maintaining content -> larger role for Wiki; lesser role for Drupal
    • Content organization/re-organization
    • Facelift? (In consultation with Jeremy - he is against this.: JM)
  • Mendeley vs. Biblio
    • Improved discoverability & functionality?
    • All content in one location?
    • Get a Library Science grad student to help us with our document repository concerns (I asked Greg R. to look for someone: JM)

Tools Knowledge in the Community

    • Developing a strategy for sharing what tools are out there
  • Sharing information about skills researchers need to use particular tools
    • Could get lots of info from iPlant and Data Carpentry about the skills problems people run into when trying to use any of the community tools for research.
      • Use this to strategically point people to where they can transform their data, or learn a skill.
    • NOTE: skills needed are mostly the same across the data providers and researchers based on the experience of COLLAB-IT, Data and Software Carpentry.
  • Everyone watch this video together (DP, KL, MC)
  • The value of blitzes and hackathons


Value added services

  • Annotations workflows - Analyzing the needs, expectations and desires of submitters, curators, and observers around the collection and presentation of annotations.
  • The new iDigBio Outlier Detection and Documentation by Collectors (or the ODD Collectors) Working Group (Austin and Katie S)

E&O

  • New directions for the Libraries of Life Augmented Reality app and cards; sustainability of them (Austin)
  • New directions for WeDigBio and its sustainability (Austin and Libby)

Other